I broke out one of the Wittes yesterday evening with dinner, but didn’t feel like reviewing. I’m glad I did wait, because even in the space of 18 hours, it has improved even more. The early-sample off-putting nose has vanished, and the resulting brew is well-nuanced and quite tasty.
Here’s the breakdown:
Appearance: Very cloudy, with thin white lacing. It looks somewhat like liquid peach in the glass. The photos keep coming out with a redder hue than it actually is — a nice shade of orange tan. 3.5
Aroma: A fruity bouquet! I promise that no fruit flavorings were added past the organic peel (3/4 oz, added in the last 10 minutes of the boil). Banana, pomegranate, lemon, orange, peach, apple, strawberry — they all make a cameo. Also, notes of honey, with a tinge of sweet-and-sour. 4.0
Taste: Not as strong as the nose, but let it breathe for a couple of minutes and it opens up very nicely. Refreshing for sure. The coriander (I used 2 teaspoons, added with the orange peel) comes right on through. There’s a citrus edge, some floral action, and a nice mild and gentle hop finish. This is one well-balanced package. 3.7
Palate: Just a tiny bit syrupy on the way down; past that it’s mostly great and definitely thirst-quenching. 3.0
Overall: I’m damn proud of this one and impressed with myself. In retrospect, I probably could have boosted that coriander on up to a Tablespoon, and next time I’ll get a bit more creative with the spices (cardamom? chamomile? definitely.) I’m imagining all sorts of food pairings, not the least of which being some sweet-and-sour bird action (duck, anyone?), seafood (lemon-butter lobster or crayfish), and even fruit dessert (warm apple pie or peach custard with some vanilla ice cream). 3.7
Overall Score (out of 5): 3.8